Quickly review your physical exam skills, and make evidence informed clinical decisions. All while earning CME Credit.

  • CME Credits icon

What is the evidence for adherence to exercise therapy in the treatment of osteoarthritis of the knee?

Summary

Patient Population:

No information was provided on the patient population.

Intervention:

Interventions designed to improve adherence to exercise recommendations. Delivered in: primary care, outpatient or community-based settings.

Comparison:

Comparison groups included “usual care”, wait listed control groups, education or advice, other exercise programs or therapeutic interventions (e.g. therapeutic ultrasound). There were 42 trials (described in a total of 59 papers) included in the present review. All but one of the included studies were RCTs. Delphi scores ranged from 2-8 overall (average score = 5). The majority of trials were considered to be of moderate methodological quality; 6 poor quality trials were identified. 23 trials studied individuals with OA (n=4894); these focused on the knee most often. The authors grouped trials into 5 broad categories – those examining 1) type of exercise therapy, 2) delivery of exercise, 3) exercise + specific adherence component 4) self-management programs and 5) interventions based on cognitive/behavioural principles.

Outcome:

  1. Exercise type is not an important factor in adherence. Level = Silver, GRADE = Moderate.
  2. There is conflicting evidence regarding water-based exercise. Level=Sliver, GRADE = Low.
  3. Supervised exercise is more effective for improving weekly training frequency than unsupervised exercise (Level = silver; GRADE=moderate).
  4. Attendance at exercise sessions may be better for individual vs. group exercise (Level=silver; GRADE=Moderate).
  5. Supplementing home exercise with group exercise may improve activity levels (Level=silver, GRADE=moderate).
  6. Accuracy of exercise performance may be improved by offering either refresher sessions or audio/videotapes of exercise sessions (Level=Silver, GRADE=Low).
  7. Interventions intended to address adherence specifically may be effective in improving frequency/duration of exercise as well as attendance at exercise sessions (Level=Silver, GRADE; Moderate).
  8. The addition of counselling based on the trans-theoretical model of change to physiotherapy does not appear to be associated with benefit when compared to physiotherapy alone (Level=Silver; GRADE = Moderate).
  9. Self-management programs improve exercise frequency compared to wait listed or no intervention control groups (Level=Silver, GRADE = Moderate).
  10. Behavioural graded activity is effective in improving adherence to a home exercise program (Level=silver; GRADE = Moderate).
  11. Interventions based on cognitive behavioural therapy may be effective for improving adherence in individuals with whiplash-based disorder (Level=silver; GRADE=moderate).
  12. CBT-based approaches may not be as effective in other chronic MSK patient groups (Level=silver, GRADE=Moderate).

Guideline Recommendations

Source Recommendation
ACR (2019) Strongly recommended

CME Information / Site Feedback

Your Name (required)

Your Email (required)

1. What is the impact of this information on you or your practice?

Note: Check all that apply. You may check more than one box.

 I learned something new I am motivated to learn more This information confirmed I did (am doing) the right thing I am reassured I am reminded of something I already knew I am dissatisfied There is a problem with the presentation of this information I disagree with the content of this information This information is potentially harmful

2. Is this information relevant for at least one of your patients?

 Totally relevant Partially relevant Not relevant

3. Will you use this information for a specific patient?

 Yes No Possibly I already know about this information, and I'm Already Using it.

4. Please rate the websites ease of use.

1 2 3 4 5 

5. Likelihood of using site again/recommending the site.

1 2 3 4 5 

Additional Information

×

Example AMSTAR Information

example amstar rating guidlines example amstar rating guidlines ×