Quickly review your physical exam skills, and make evidence informed clinical decisions. All while earning CME Credit.

  • CME Credits icon

What is the evidence for nutritional supplementation in the treatment of osteoarthritis of the knee?

Summary

Patient Population:

No information on patient population was provided.

Intervention:

  1. Various micronutrients: selenium, zinc, copper, 6mg/day boron
  2. Vitamins: >75mg vitamin C, 3000mg/day vitamin b3 for 12 weeks, 4000 IU vitamin D3
  3. Nutracueticals: glucosamine
  4. ASU: Sterol-rich, lipid fraction from avocado or soybeans. 300mg/day.
  5. S-Adenosyl-Methionene (SAMe): 800-1600mg/day for 12 weeks.
  6. Bioflavonoid polyphenols: 500mg BID
  7. Ginger/ginger extract

Comparison:

Some studies compared supplementation to a placebo group, however, a large number did not report the comparison group. Most studies focused on knee OA, but occasionally also included hip and shoulder OA.

Outcome:

  1. Vitamin C: associated with reduced risk for cartilage loss, knee pain and OA progression (no comparison group listed).
  2. Vitamin E: in small clinical trials, associated with improved pain and stiffness (no comparison group listed).
  3. Vitamin D: conflicting evidence, may be more important in earlier stages of OA and younger patients (<60 y/o) – (no comparison group listed).
  4. Vitamin B3: 1 RCT was associated with improved mobility, reduced inflammation and reduction in NSAID use – similar results in a parallel group study using age matched controls (no comparison group listed).
  5. Selenium, Vitamin’s A, C, and E: 1 RCT was associated with improvement in pain and stiffness (vs. placebo).
  6. Boron: 1 RCT was associated with improved pain and function (vs. placebo).
  7. Glucosamine: associated with improvements in pain and function, reduces the risk for joint replacement and stabilizes cartilage degeneration (no comparison group listed).
  8. ASU: several small (non-RCT) studies were associated with improved pain and decreased NSAID use (vs. placebo).
  9. S-Adenosyl-Methionene (SAMe): 2 small studies associated with similar improvements to NSAID treatment with a longer effect than NSAIDs (no comparison group listed).
  10. Bioflavonoid polyphenols: 2 clinical trials were associated with improved joint function, a good safety profile and low toxicity, and (1 non-inferiority trial) as effective as naproxen (no comparison group listed for the 2 clinical trials).
  11. Ginger/ginger extract: 2 RCTs were associated with improved scores on WOMAC and VAS-pain index over short and long term (no comparison group listed).

Guideline Recommendations

Source Recommendation
NICE 2014 - glucosamine & chondroitin Do Not Recommend

Relevant Clinical Info

NO AMSTAR SCORE RECORDED

CME Information / Site Feedback

Your Name (required)

Your Email (required)

1. What is the impact of this information on you or your practice?

Note: Check all that apply. You may check more than one box.

 I learned something new I am motivated to learn more This information confirmed I did (am doing) the right thing I am reassured I am reminded of something I already knew I am dissatisfied There is a problem with the presentation of this information I disagree with the content of this information This information is potentially harmful

2. Is this information relevant for at least one of your patients?

 Totally relevant Partially relevant Not relevant

3. Will you use this information for a specific patient?

 Yes No Possibly I already know about this information, and I'm Already Using it.

4. Please rate the websites ease of use.

1 2 3 4 5 

5. Likelihood of using site again/recommending the site.

1 2 3 4 5 

Additional Information

×

Example AMSTAR Information

example amstar rating guidlines example amstar rating guidlines ×